VAR needs to be binned, says West Ham forward Michail Antonio

by Steven Smith
4 minutes read
West Ham had a goal disallowed after Jarrod Bowen was adjudged to have fouled keeper Edouard Mendy in the build up
West Ham had a goal disallowed after Jarrod Bowen was adjudged to have fouled keeper Edouard Mendy in the build up
Listen to the latest episode of The Footballer’s Football Podcast on BBC Sounds.

West Ham forward Michail Antonio says the video assistant referee (VAR) system needs to be “binned”.

The Hammers were controversially denied a 90th-minute equaliser at Chelsea on Saturday after VAR intervened.

Referees’ body PGMOL effectively accepted that decision – and a second VAR call at Newcastle United v Crystal Palace – was wrong.

“It was a madness, that’s what I am going to call it. An actual madness,” said Antonio.

Speaking on the latest episode of the Footballer’s Football Podcast on BBC Sounds, he added: “I have said this many times. It needs to be binned.”

  • PGMOL accepts VAR decisions at Chelsea & Newcastle were wrong
  • Does Premier League have a problem using VAR?
  • Is it time to bin VAR? Listen, download and subscribe to the Footballer’s Football Podcast

The PGMOL said it will fully co-operate with a Premier League review of last weekend’s incidents.

The system is in its fourth full Premier League season after it was introduced in 2019. The Premier League claimed the percentage of correct “key match decisions” rose from 82% without it to 94% in that first season.

The purposeexternal-link is for the VAR to flag “clear and obvious errors” or “serious missed incidents” to advise the on-field referee.

It is only used for goals, penalty decisions, straight red cards or mistaken identity – and there is a “high bar” for intervention “to maintain the pace and intensity of matches”.

Maxwell Cornet thought he levelled at 2-2 for West Ham at Stamford Bridge but, after being told to look at the monitor by VAR, referee Andrew Madley decided there was a foul on keeper Edouard Mendy by Jarrod Bowen and reversed his decision to award a goal.

West Ham manager David Moyes called the decision to disallow his side’s goal as “scandalous”.

David Moyes says VAR decision was ‘scandalous’

“As a player we all knew it [the incident] was nothing,” said Antonio.

“It is all about opinions – about the referee’s opinion, about the fourth official’s opinion and about the opinion of whoever is watching,” added Antonio.

“If the referee makes a decision, then there is another person who goes ‘that might not be the right decision’. He goes to the referee ‘you might have to have another look at that’.

“He is putting doubt in the referee’s mind when he is already sure about the decision he has made.

“He goes over and watches [on the monitor] but because someone has already said to him you might have got that wrong – it has clouded his mind already.

“The person who is meant to make a decision, who is quite sure of his decision, believes his decision is right, has now got that doubt and feels he needs to change – or if he doesn’t change [wonders] if he is going to get into trouble because another referee has told him to change.

“It is taking the passion away from football because you don’t know if you have scored or not – it is pointless.

“You are spending all this money on VAR for things to still go wrong.”

‘It’s no good apologising on the Monday’

At Newcastle, Crystal Palace defender Tyrick Mitchell turned the ball into his own net only for referee Michael Salisbury to eventually rule the goal out for a foul by Joe Willock on goalkeeper Vicente Guaita, following VAR intervention.

Newcastle felt midfielder Willock was himself pushed by Mitchell into Guaita.

The game ended 0-0 and Magpies striker Callum Wilson told the Footballer’s Football Podcast: “VAR had a bad weekend.

“Ultimately, it’s making the game a little bit more messy than it needs to be. Technology for things that they are getting wrong like offsides, bring VAR in – it’s good for that. But, when you are denying a goal for a little tug or the ball hits your arm and then all of a sudden it flies in, it’s crazy.

“We should only be using VAR for decisions that are blatant and obvious.

“It’s no good apologising on the Monday because you’ve got the decision wrong on the Saturday. That’s cost us two points. Come the end of the season, two points could be the difference between a team staying up and going down.”

He added: “It’s not going to go away. I can’t see them getting rid of it at all so we’ve just got to learn to live with it but use it properly.”

‘It’s beyond terrible’ – Alan Shearer on ‘shocking’ VAR decisions
  • Our coverage of your Premier League club is bigger and better than ever before – follow your team and sign up for notifications in the BBC Sport app to make sure you never miss a moment

You may also like

This file is for domain verification. copyright This file is for domain verification. copyright